Cheesy BLT is a special recipe that can be selected by players to be the "Special of the Day" in Papa's Cheeseria/To Go!. Customers coming in can choose this special instead of their regular order. Customers who order the Cheesy BLT special will give you 1.5 . The special prize for this recipe is the Chef Hat (PC) and the Two-Tone Henley (To Go!).
- Austin's order is almost identical to the Cheesy BLT except using white bread and Awesome Sauce, in replacement for their corresponding ingredients.