Colby Jack Cheese is a standard topping available in Papa's Pizzeria To Go!. It is unlocked with Sasha when the player reaches Rank 7. The "Cheese Please" badge is earned when the player serves 30 pizza orders with Colby Jack Cheese.
Marble Colby Cheese is a standard cheese available in Papa's Cheeseria/To Go!. It is available at the start of the game. In Papa's Cheeseria, the "Keepin' it Colby" badge is earned when the player serves 30 orders with Marble Colby Cheese.