For other uses, see Nutty Buttercup (disambiguation)

Nutty Butter Cup is an ingredient used in various Papa Louie's restaurant time-management games.

In Papa's Freezeria/HD/To Go!, it is a standard mixable available at the start of the game. The "Peanut Buttery" badge is given when the player serves 20 sundaes with Nutty Butter Cups.

In Papa's Cupcakeria/To Go!/HD, it is a standard topping unlocked with Hugo when the player reaches Rank 9. The "Peanut Buttery" badge is given when the player serves this to 30 customers.

Customers who order this


Freezeria HD

Nutty Butter Cups

Freezeria To Go!



Nutter Butter cup

Cupcakeria To Go!

Unlocking nutty butter cup

Cupcakeria HD


  • In Freezeria/HD/To Go!, Allan is the only person to order Nutty Butter Cups with banana syrup. The other customers order them with either vanilla or chocolate syrup. Excluding Jojo, this is never ordered with Rainbow Sherbet Syrup, Mint, or Strawbery Syrup.
  • These are Flipline's version of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
  • According to his Flipdeck, Allan loves Nutty Butter Cups.


Appears in Picture Bonus Points Cost Theme
Papa's Freezeria
Nutty Butter Cup
Nutty Butter Bonus N/A $35.00 N/A
Papa's Cupcakeria/To Go!/HD
Nutty Butter Cups (Freezeria HD)
Nutty Butter Cups Bonus 30 points Earned

in mini-game

Thanksgiving icon
Papa's Freezeria HD
Nutty Butter Cups (Freezeria HD)
Nutty Butter Bonus 30 points $50.00 TacodaleMia
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.