This page is about one of the forty pie specials from Papa's Bakeria . If your looking for the entry of Nutty Butter Cups, please visit this page.

Nutty Buttercup is a Special Pie that can be selected by players to be the "Today's Special" in Papa's Bakeria. Customers coming in can choose this special instead of their regular order. Customers who ask for the Nutty Buttercup will give 190% of the normal points. The special prize for mastering this recipe is the Beret.



Crust Chocolate Crust
Pie Filling Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
Top Crust Vented Crust
Toppings Chocolate Mousse (Outer Ring)
9 Butterscotch Smooches (Inner Ring and Center)


ve Papa's Bakeria Special Pies
Special Pies Apple CrispBanana CreamBanana SplitBanoffee PieCaramel AppleCherry CheesecakeCherry CordialCitri-ShockCloud NineCocoa Key LimeCreameo CheesecakeDerby PieFluffernutterFrench SilkGraceland KingGranny SmithKiwi StrawberryLemon MeringueLuau PunchMallow HaupiaMississippi MudNeapolitan PieNutty ButtercupOrchard TartPeach CobblerPineapple Upside DownPink LemonadePiña CooladaPlantain CrunchPrune CreekRhuby TuberRocky RoadRoyal AnneS'mores PieShoofly PieSouthern PecanSugar DragonStrawberry RhubarbTiramisu (Pie)Wild Berry