Scary Sugar Eyes are holiday-exclusive mixables available during Halloween in Papa's Scooperia/HD/To Go!. They are unlocked with Iggy when the player reaches Rank 44.
Customers who order this ingredient[]
- Iggy (Unlocked)
- Akari
- Elle
- Professor Fitz
- Rudy
- Vincent
- Willow
- Crystal (Closer)
- Quinn (Closer)
- Whippa (Closer)
Posters[]
| Appears in | Picture | Bonus | Points | Cost | Theme |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Papa's Scooperia/HD/To Go! |  |
Scary Sugar Eyes Bonus | 20 points | $40.00 | 
|