Shoofly Pie is a special recipe that can be selected by players to be the "Special of the Day" in Papa's Bakeria/To Go!. Customers who order a Shoofly Pie special will give the player 2.5x 
. The special prizes for mastering this recipe are the Groovy Headband (Bakeria) and the Striped Buttondown (To Go!). The special can be unlocked once the player reaches Rank 9 and unlocks Polka Dot Crust.
Recipe[]
| Crust | Creameo Crust |
|---|---|
| Pie Filling | Toffee Filling |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Top Crust | Polka Dot Crust |
| Toppings | Chocolate Mousse (Outer Ring) |
Trivia[]
- The "Try Some Toffee" sticker is earned when the player serves a Shoofly Pie to Prudence.
- Shoofly Pie is based off a real-life dessert. It is named so because of its sweet odor that attracts flies that must be "shooed".
Gallery[]
Order ticket
A Shoofly Pie
Special prize (Bakeria)
Special prize (To Go!)
| v • e Papa's Bakeria/To Go! Specials | |
|---|---|
| Special Pies | Apple Crisp • Banana Cream • Banana Split • Banoffee Pie • Caramel Apple • Cherry Cheesecake • Cherry Cordial • Citri-Shock • Cloud Nine • Cocoa Key Lime • Creameo Cheesecake • Derby Pie • Fluffernutter • French Silk • Graceland King • Granny Smith • Kiwi Strawberry • Lemon Meringue • Luau Punch • Mallow Haupia • Mississippi Mud • Neapolitan Pie • Nutty Buttercup • Orchard Tart • Peach Cobbler • Pineapple Upside Down • Pink Lemonade • Piña Coolada • Plantain Crunch • Prune Creek • Rhuby Tuber • Rocky Road • Royal Anne • S'mores Pie • Shoofly Pie • Southern Pecan • Sugar Dragon • Strawberry Rhubarb • Tiramisu • Wild Berry |