Shoofly Pie is a special recipe that can be selected by players to be the "Special of the Day" in Papa's Bakeria/To Go!. Customers who order the Shoofly Pie special will give the player 2.5x Coin. The special prizes for this recipe are the Groovy Headband (PC) and the Striped Buttondown (To Go!).


Crust Creameo Crust
Pie Filling Toffee Filling
Toffee Filling
Toffee Filling
Toffee Filling
Top Crust Polka Dot Crust
Toppings Chocolate Mousse (Outer Ring)


  • Shoofly Pie is based off a real life dessert. It is named so because of its sweet odor that attracts flies that must be "shooed".
  • Sticker 65 " Try Some Toffee" is earned by serving Shoofly Pie to Prudence.


ve Papa's Bakeria/To Go! Specials
Special Pies Apple CrispBanana CreamBanana SplitBanoffee PieCaramel AppleCherry CheesecakeCherry CordialCitri-ShockCloud NineCocoa Key LimeCreameo CheesecakeDerby PieFluffernutterFrench SilkGraceland KingGranny SmithKiwi StrawberryLemon MeringueLuau PunchMallow HaupiaMississippi MudNeapolitan PieNutty ButtercupOrchard TartPeach CobblerPineapple Upside DownPink LemonadePiña CooladaPlantain CrunchPrune CreekRhuby TuberRocky RoadRoyal AnneS'mores PieShoofly PieSouthern PecanSugar DragonStrawberry RhubarbTiramisuWild Berry
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.